| Re: CloseUp1 2006: Top Five: Old songs! Thanks a lot again Teol vai for quick sharing. Ajker performance e Muhin and Ronty ke best mone hoyese amar. and then Salma and Nisitha. But I have noticed some facts in the program also in the eyes of judges. First of all, It should an equal opportunity for all the clntestants. They showed some previews of the original film during Muhin's and Ronty's performance but what abt the others?? If they dont have any clips for other songs they must not show it only for two contestants. Because of these clips their songs looked visually more appealing than others. Though I beleive that Muhin and Ronty performed better than others but still it should be equal opportunity for everyone. Next thing is the attitude of the judges. We are general people, some of us like Salma, some of us like Muhin or Ronty and we try to express our feelings in different forums. Judges do have their personal likings and dislikings too but they must not mix up their personal likings with their professional and neutral judgement. Even ajker show dekhanor agei Fahmida nobi paper e interview diyese ei bole .. Muhin er performance khub valo silo and Salma oto valo korte pareni. This is not fair. I also lile Muhin and Ronty but even being an ordinary person I am not trying to force anyone. I know there are lots of people who likes Salma more than anyone and I am not going to argue with them saying .. hei dont be emotional, be rational and so and so. But judges are doing this kind of things. They are not ordinary people, all the closeup1 viewers are listening their comments and Great power comes with Great responsibility. Where is their responsibility?? Even sometimes one of them saying to some contestants that .. u r a Kohinur Diamond and other is trying to prove that she is not even glass (remember PUTUL??). Salma and Nisita .. I guess both of them appeared to be Frankenstein to the judges. Suru thekei Salma and Nisitha ke ektu besi posondo kore eseche judge ra. 2nd Rond e Salma er gaan sesh e Bulbul er kotha bondho hoye jawa or Nisitha er gaan sune Fahmida nobi er .. ki bolbo ami, ja bolar tumi e bole dao .. ei bole vasha hariye fela. Muhin, Kisore and Ronty keo jugde ra praise korese suru thekei but Salma and Nisitha ke surute jevabe praise korese oder to koreni. And Now ei dujon jokhon judge der point or comment er porowa na korei onek sms passe judge ra tokhon ki ektu palti kheye gelo naki?? Ajke Nisitha and Salma dujonkei samanno rude comment korese FN eijonne bollam ei kotha gulo. I am sure sujog pele Salma ke aro kisu negative bolto FAhmida Nobi but Bulbul er voy e bolte pareni. Putul er case e to sudhu khepe giyesilo Bulbul, Salma ke niye besi kisu ulta palta bolle maramari lagiye dite pare. However, amar eto lomba boktobber uddesso particular kono performer ke support kora na. I was just confused with the attitude of the closeup1 organizers and Judges. Hotath kore Salma and Nisitha er tader favourite child the step child e porinoto hober karon bujhte parsi na. Eta ki Jonogon er vote ar tader point na milar karone jealousy or ego problem naki onno kisu?? Goto 2 round theke unara din raat jonogon ke upodesh diye jassen jati, dhormo, elaka, institution eisob niye biased na hoye or emotional na hoye perfectly judge korte. But they should follow their advice first and show an example to the viewers. |