View Single Post
  #30  
Old 12-09-2006, 06:25 PM
TeolABM's Avatar
TeolABM TeolABM is offline
Super Moderator
 
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Malmö, Sweden.
Posts: 2,614
Thanks: 1,387
Thanked 7,982 Times in 330 Posts
Rep Power: 149
TeolABM has a reputation beyond repute
TeolABM has a reputation beyond reputeTeolABM has a reputation beyond reputeTeolABM has a reputation beyond reputeTeolABM has a reputation beyond reputeTeolABM has a reputation beyond reputeTeolABM has a reputation beyond reputeTeolABM has a reputation beyond reputeTeolABM has a reputation beyond reputeTeolABM has a reputation beyond reputeTeolABM has a reputation beyond reputeTeolABM has a reputation beyond repute
UL: 2.00 tb DL: 353.92 gb Ratio: 5.79
Re: CloseUp1 2006: Top Five: Old songs!

Quote:
Originally Posted by tarunno
Thanks Teol Bahi for this program. I have few observations about the closeup1 this time. The judges always talk about Bangla culture and its origin. But I haven’t found the Polligeti Round this time which was present in the previous occasion. There were many episodes but they dropped that special round. Now we have 5 participants and I haven’t heard 4 of them singing any Polli Giti at all. I have no doubt about the performance of Muhin and Ronty but they haven’t sung any such song. So if closeup1 should be able to perform all types of songs, why this one is neglected? If I am not wrong this is an inseparable part of the bangle culture. We know how good salma and polash are in these songs. Salma is performing modern songs now and getting harsh comments from the judge but this is not her area. Why not put others in her area and observe how they perform/ I believe they will do good but people should know about it. If they are so concern about the culture they should think about this attitude. There is one episode to go and I am sure that it will be deshatoo bodhok song.
i agree with you more than 100%. why polligiti is neglected? there should be a round for only mystical and folksongs. then we will be able to see that the participants are able to sing all kind of songs. as you said, 4 of them never sang any folk or polligiti, so how we can judge them that they can sing all kinds of songs? such kind of comments from the judges are irrelavant!

it is clear now that judges, especially Kumar and Fahmida are openly against Salma and Nishita. they shouldnt propogate agaisnt someone or campaign for someone who like!

thanks for the posts!
Reply With Quote
 
Page generated in 0.10593 seconds with 18 queries