View Single Post
  #44  
Old 12-21-2006, 12:24 AM
pordeshi pordeshi is offline
Inquisitive
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 16
Thanks: 1
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Rep Power: 0
pordeshi is on a distinguished road
UL: 531.23 mb DL: 129.78 mb Ratio: 4.09
Re: CloseUp1 '06: Top 4: Result!

Quote:
Originally Posted by TeolABM
Salma was getting very high votes from the audience long before her father commented about their family condition. his comment was simple and nothing to do with make people sympathicised to vote his daughter. so you cannot compare Salma with Nolok. last year ntv was showing the family condisiton earlier than this year.

but you can say that Muhin's kannakati made people vote for him enormously and it is true. he was singing well even earlier dounds. on the other hand, Salma did better performence in the last round than other two rounds, and still she got less vote.
Thanks TeolABM for your explanation.

actually I was talking about some newspapers too, they discovered Salma's family condition long before her father commented it on NTV. So ppl knew about her family condition from the begining. Anyway I am not saying she got only sympathy votes, but some extend it helped her to get more votes.

On the other hand, about Muhin, I don't know why he cried on that day!!! NTV could delete that portion, may be it was intentional. But I have to say his performance was excellent, and I also cried with him. I don't think only for crying he got 4 lakhs vote. At this point not only me, lot of other ppl also think he is the best among 3.

I am upset about Ronty. She was 2nd best and she was out. But Nishita, her performance was so poor and she got 43 from judges. To me Salma and Nishita's performances were below 40 standard. They got more points than they deserved. Again it's my opinion only.

Thanks all.
Reply With Quote
 
Page generated in 0.06807 seconds with 18 queries