I agree with you. It would be very fair if Muhin, Salma, Nishita receives these points from judges. I am not sure why some of us bashing F. Nabi? If I was a judge my comments would not differ from F. Nabi. It is a competition judges has right to explain singers and viewers what is their faults.

Muhin - deserves to be closeup1. Nice voice and good singing style, has educational musical background (in a competition like closeup1 it is very important). Judges should give him 48-50.

Salma - I guess deserves 2nd best, because her voice has village accent and 80% ppl likes that accent. Even though I don't, to me in a music competition Salma's pronounciation problem is a big problem (Pran-> Pan, Prio->Pio). If ppl vote her that's not Salma's fault (I guess she earned it!), but if jugdes gives her low points (35-40) I don't think it will be unfair.

Nishita - I liked her performance this time, specially her moulik song. But still she had some problem with high nodes... . I will not surprise if she over takes Salma. I think she should get 40-43 from judges. But I will be happy if she takes 3rd place.

Salma and Nishita both has limitations, and I don't think they deserve to be closeup1.