View Single Post
  #52  
Old 12-24-2006, 03:21 AM
TeolABM's Avatar
TeolABM TeolABM is offline
Super Moderator
 
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Malmö, Sweden.
Posts: 2,616
Thanks: 1,388
Thanked 7,933 Times in 330 Posts
Rep Power: 148
TeolABM has a reputation beyond repute
TeolABM has a reputation beyond reputeTeolABM has a reputation beyond reputeTeolABM has a reputation beyond reputeTeolABM has a reputation beyond reputeTeolABM has a reputation beyond reputeTeolABM has a reputation beyond reputeTeolABM has a reputation beyond reputeTeolABM has a reputation beyond reputeTeolABM has a reputation beyond reputeTeolABM has a reputation beyond reputeTeolABM has a reputation beyond repute
UL: 2.00 tb DL: 353.92 gb Ratio: 5.79
Re: CloseUp1 '06: Final Round: Salma is the Best!

Quote:
Originally Posted by pordeshi

Salma - I guess deserves 2nd best, because her voice has village accent and 80% ppl likes that accent. Even though I don't, to me in a music competition Salma's pronounciation problem is a big problem (Pran-> Pan, Prio->Pio). If ppl vote her that's not Salma's fault (I guess she earned it!), but if jugdes gives her low points (35-40) I don't think it will be unfair.
nana munir nana mot. and same accusation again against Salma. i dont know from which part of BD you came as you found pronounciation problem of Salma where we dont find any wrong as it was in the original songs. if you are from Dhaka then you are right. for example, many of the songs of Hasaon Raja are in local Sylheti language. if Salma would have done any pronounciatin mistake then our hostile judges like F.Nabi and Kumar B.Jit woult not leave her without criticising. but Nishita had that kind of problem.

and your supporitng of the marks, i dont agree with. i even dont even agree with you about the judges attitueds towards our youngest competetor Salma. you may read some some leading newspapers from BD where NTV and some of the judges attitudes were openly criticised. do you think it is fair when in the Desher Gaan round ntv only showed some background scenes with Muhin and Ronty's songs? they were bisaded and in the final round you will notice that both F.Nabi and Kumar were more careful on criticising of Salma.

to understand mystic and boul songs of our culture you need to feel it from the heart. for instance, even some years ago people would look down upon singers who sing folklore. but now you see modern and band musicians after folklore. they collect the famous and popular songs from the country-side and make some changes and sing. if you are a fan of band songs then it will be hard for you to judge the real folklore.

one more thing: in which part of Bangladesh the real Bangali is spoken? the answer is not Dhaka but Kushtia from where Salma comes. so before croticising her pronounciatin remember this fact. even illiterate people speak pure Bangla there.
Reply With Quote
 
Page generated in 0.07581 seconds with 18 queries