Shudhu yorker na,:nono: Clean Bold

__________________
shan@banglatorrents.com

"Morning Shows the Days"........amee class 6 e porar somoy english rapid reader e poresilaam.Salma r sathey r kaokey tulona kora ki thik hobey ?amaar to money hoy o
god gifted talented.or vitorey asey ek dhoroner mohito korar khomota.sudhu tai noy,
boyos olpo,ovinoy ba onukoroner protiva,abong sorbopori carhisma.....ameeto money
kori Salma,Ronty,Muhin, amader Third generation er
( after 1971) high breed der ek ek jon protinidhi.

Thanks
Babu
Delray Beach,FL

__________________
Regards
Babu
Boca Raton,FL

Long Live BT !

All "biased/emotional" bd people is with her. I have nothing against Salma. She has excellent voice. She is the youngest. She comes from an insolvent family - which makes her achievements all the more amazing.

BUT that does NOT justify voting blindly for her. We should vote for the person who sings best in that particular round. If Salma sings best in a particular round then I won't hesitate to vote for her. On the other hand, if I feel someone else has fared better - then I would go for that guy/girl. Ultimately, it should all come down to performance - and NOTHING else.

These emotional "hujuge" voters are making the whole competition pointless. The current situation is such that other singers know that no matter how much better they perform than Salma, she is going to get the top position by dint of these "blind" votes. Will those "blind" fans of Salma ever think how cruel and unfair this situation is for those other four singers?

hi, i marked the comment of you with red and bold. we felt offended by these word. so, please avoid such kind of words and attitudes next time when you argue for something. we apprecate peoples comments and views. we are different and shoudl have different arguments. but we shoudnot hurt others feelings.

i am not arguing with you abt Salma. but one thing even if the fans of Salma are biased, this is her credit that she could draw so many people towards her with her excellent voice, style, simplicity and plainness. that is no way less!

thanks for understanding.

Thanx a lot ToelABM Vai..You tell the truth Behind Salma's fan..

__________________
Im In Luv With My SadNess

Hi TeolABM Bhai,

I apologize wholeheartedly if I have offended anyone in this forum by my post. But I personally didn't think that words like "biased" or "emotional" or "hujuge" are offending words. "Hujuge Bangali" is very often used to describe our characteristics. As for the word "biased", you have sort of indirectly admitted the fact that many Salma fans are probably biased because of some inherent qualities of Salma (which I myself also appreciate). This actually shows that the word "biased" is not an offending one either.

Anyway, I would humbly request the voters to put themselves in other singer's shoes and realize how it feels to be wronged because of something beyond their control. It is not their fault that they have come from a more solvent background than Salma. As I have said before, what Salma has achieved from her background is simply astonishing. But she is already in top 5. She is going to tour USA, Canada and Europe anyway. She is going to get a lot of cash as well as prizemoney. I guess jonogon has done their part already by supporting Salma up to this point. So from now on, let us vote for the best performer. If Salma deserves our votes by her performance in next rounds then so be it. On the other hand, if someone else outclasses Salma by his/her performance (as it was the case in band row) then let us give that person what he/she truly deserves.

Thanks everyone.

Dear napoleon,
Thanks for your valuable realization and a diplomatic reply. I had decided not to post any more on this thread. But could not help myself posting this one.
I am not going to argue with you about Salma.
With due restpect to your opinion ,I would like to request you to read the # 8 Post on this thread By sahmed once again. That might give you a clear and concize perception of the reason why people vote for her.
As we are looking for someone who can represent Bangladesh (according to F Nabi), not the person who is gonna get the big(?) money, people should have their own choice of representation and ofcurse its variable .
However .we never know what gonna happen after 10 years ,and being some one closeup1 will not make change to our individual life either.
So ,you keep voting your favorite and i will do for mine. Time will say whats wrong, whats right.
Thank you very much.:bestwishe

__________________
shan@banglatorrents.com

100% agreed! Very well-thought.

__________________

Shan & TeolABM , I totally agree with you guys. "napoleonIV" not only offended the BT members but also offended the vast majority of the people who voted for Salma. By talking about the prize money he/she has proved his mentality. This is the first time I saw someone is concerned about prize money. Thats relly rediculous. I believe jonogon (public) never made mistake. So time will say who is wrong and who is right. So better to wait.:bestwishe to Salma

:flamethro I believe jonogon (public) never made mistake
"Biased" word ta use korate ato offended howar ki holo ami thik bujhlam na. Eta kono 'slang' or 'abusive' language na je eta use korle offended feel korte hobe. Ami still shondihan Salma je 3,00,000 vote paay taar koto jon really Salma-r gaan shune vaalo lagay vote daay. Oi voter ra beshir vaag-i ****** ei bapare napoleanIV-er moto amar-o kono doubt naai. Word-ta aar use korlam na, ete abar keu keu offended feel korte paren.

just imagine a scenario (which is very unlikely, but just imagine)....Salma comes to the stage but forgets the whole song
How many votes will she get?
If you can answer the question honestly then you also know what the meaning of "biased" or "emotional" is.
After all, it's a contest and has consecutive rounds, which means we are supposed to judge the best singers in each round.

I guess, then she will get around 4 lakhs of votes. ;)
There will come the sympathy thing. "She is a great singer. So, forgetting the song means she will get a poor marks from the judges. So, let us vote her to pass through...in the next round, she will do again excellent" That's a fact, if you could remember the increase of Mona's votes after forgetting the song!

We should really vote based on the performance, not based on the face. Some people may put the face a higher priority though. Just like in the parliament elections, where many people vote the 'marka', not the person.

__________________

I DO AGREE WITH YOU.I THINK RONTY IS THE BEST.SHE CAN SING ALL TYPES.SHE IS LIKE SAMINA CHOWDHURY.
:bestwishe

Great post !

You have certainly asked a very good question. I am pretty sure that if something like that happens (God forbid - I do not want anything like that to happen to any contestant), Salma will still get those 3 lakh votes - plus some additional votes to make up for any potential undermarking by the judges.

I am afraid you have misunderstood why I mentioned about money. It was probably my fault that I didn't make it clear. So let me explain it.

I talked about money, foreign tours, etc just to emphasize the point that Salma has already got the necessary platform to go to the next level as singer. She is immensely talented and with the right kind of exposure - she will achieve a lot in future. But from her background, it was very hard to get that initially. People of Bangladesh has done a great job by supporting her up to this point. But lets now try to vote objectively.

To summarise, I mentioned about prizemoney and other things to stress the fact that Salma no longer needs any "blind" votes to fulfill her potential.

I hope I was able to make myself clear.

Thanks.

you again drew an unnecessary debate on the fact. do you think people vote for Salma because of sympathy on her background? do you think we three lacs people dont understant how important it is to find the really talented and genious who can represent the country? it is itself offense. as you said earlier that the time will prove what is wrong or eight. why not you stay on that statement?

if we all think that only one person is capable of being top1 then we all have voted for one person. think what would happen to others? we all are different and offcourse have different views. if you like it then there is no necessary of unnecessary debate. if you dont then respect others' view.

vote for who YOU consider the best! we will do ours!