Result: Closeup1 06: Top Five! - Page 3

karinawish · #41 12-13-2006, 11:14 PM

Dream vai, NTVr oi kajta amar ekebarei posondo hoyni. Agerbarer top 10 ke jiggesh kora uchit hoyni. Tar modhdhe Nolok absent!

NTV is unfair: seems, they are campaigning against Salma
judges are unfair: Some of them are Salma and Nishita fans and Fahmida is a Salma hater
the public is also unfair: In the last round Salma and Nishita dont deserves this many votes.

Anyway, the world is not fair and luck controles everything.
I just wish good luck to the best participant, whoever it be!

**rihaad** · #42 12-13-2006, 11:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by karinawish

Dream vai, NTVr oi kajta amar ekebarei posondo hoyni. Agerbarer top 10 ke jiggesh kora uchit hoyni. Tar modhdhe Nolok absent!

NTV is unfair: seems, they are campaigning against Salma
judges are unfair: Some of them are Salma and Nishita fans and Fahmida is a Salma hater
the public is also unfair: In the last round Salma and Nishita dont deserves this many votes.

Anyway, the world is not fair and luck controles everything.
I just wish good luck to the best participant, whoever it be!

Eishob boila aar ki hobey ? People go after the face these days , who cares about the talent ? Look at here , people are voting for Salma . To be honest , she just looks like a girl from middle class family can't even speak bengali properly :) (No Offence) .

We are looking for talent , not for the face or something .

"Kishor" did do well but he failed to make it , yeah it happens but "Salma" is a girl can't even speak bengali properly , people voting for her , even Momtaz can sing better than her (no offence again) .

So , chill out guys , there are nothing to be so excited as it's not the end of the life & we do have so many otehr things to do in the life . If you look around you will see so many nicer looking girls than "Salma" & "Nishita" .

Don't forget we are looking for talent , not for the face as obvious . Hopefully you guys would be taking it easy after that , it's just a programme on "NTV" as Indian channels having atleast 20 programmes like this or better in so many Indian channels :) .

If "Salma or Nishita" win the contest then they are not get married with them who voted them for :) . Hope you guys won't forget it yet :) .......

**shan** · #43 12-14-2006, 01:05 AM

First of all thanks to Dream bhai, for his nice post after a while.Apni majhe kothay haowa hoye gelen? Ja hok nice to see you back on CloseUp1 thread.

Quote:

Originally Posted by rihaad

........ If you look around you will see so many nicer looking girls than "Salma" & "Nishita" ......
If "Salma or Nishita" win the contest they are not get married with them who voted them for :) . Hope you guys won't forget it yet :) .......

rihaad bhai, মন্তব্য নিষ্প্রয়োজন (montobbo nishproyojon):speechles

**Dream** · #44 12-14-2006, 10:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shan

First of all thanks to Dream bhai, for his nice post after a while.Apni majhe kothay haowa hoye gelen? Ja hok nice to see you back on CloseUp1 thread.

Thanks shan for those nice words. Haowa hoye jainito; bestotar kaarone majhe majhe niomioto asha hoye uthe na. Apnake abaro dhonnobad shan!

Thanks to Teol for being so regular with Closeup1 release!

shopon71 · #45 12-14-2006, 01:02 PM

i Feel Bad For Kishore. He Performed Well Over Nishita In My Opinion.

mamun93 · #46 12-14-2006, 04:12 PM

Throughout this competition, I feel really sorry to see that we keep loosing :banghead: some outstanding singers like Bappi, Era, Polash, Sabbir due to unjustified craze for some crappy (compared to Bappy, Era) singers like Nishita. Nishita looked inconfident and blant in most of the songs other than habib's songs which I think she practiced for last 1~2 years. In fact, she started to look like "a fish taken out of water" after her quota of habib's song was over. Now we see the results. In the band round, we lost Putul and now we have lost Kishor, both of them are far better singers in my opinion. I'm also doubtful about the justification of Salma's being in the top 5. Performance wise, we have lost better singers in the expense of her as well throughout the rounds of this contest.
This is solely my opinion and you need not agree with it. So, Nishita and Salma fans, no offence please.

zazabor · #47 12-14-2006, 09:47 PM

Dear Mamun93 lets talk about the future .. apnar kotha apnar type er kotha sobay bolte bolte ar sunte sunte sobay bore hoye gese .. za hobar ta to hoye ee gese..apni akhn tar kono kisuee change korte parben na..so just leave ur past opinions ..

Nishita-Salma Ze rokom ee gaan koruk .. Tader majhe akta khub valo quality ase ... seta holo Manusher mone dhuke zaowa..zeta tara 1st kisu round a korte parse..a zonno akhno ppl ra tader sathe ase.. Talent er dik diye ora onek agiye onnoder theke.. aita bolar opekkha rakhe na..

So akhn Dekha zak Kalker round a ke Badd porbe.. Deshattobodhok a Salma ar Muhin er gaan valo hobe asha kora zai .. Ronty ar Nishita r moddhe kew badd zate pare..

(aquarium ta joss hoise Admins)

**TeolABM** · #48 12-15-2006, 02:07 AM

Here is the news about tomorrows performence of top 4!

napoleonIV · #49 12-15-2006, 02:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by zazabor

Nishita-Salma Ze rokom ee gaan koruk .. .. Talent er dik diye ora onek agiye onnoder theke.. aita bolar opekkha rakhe na..

Zazabor Bhai,

I am a lay man - with little knowledge about music. I will really appreciate if you could explain your comment that no matter how they sing, they are far ahead than other in terms of talent. I am assuming you are referring to their music talent here. My little knowledge tells me that the only way to judge a singer's talent is by his/her song. Please let me know of this advanced formula by which we can judge a singer's talent irrespective of his/her song.

Thanks.

pordeshi · #50 12-15-2006, 11:07 AM

I am just dreaming now, need "Aladin's Cheerag" !!! hopefully Muhin will be closeup1, I cannot compare anyone else with him.

karinawish · #51 12-15-2006, 04:45 PM

রন্টির গানটা সবচেয়ে কঠিন। আশাকরি ভালো গাইবে। মুহিন দেশের গানে কেমন করে, দেখা যাক। সালমার এই গান চয়েসটা ভালো মনে হচ্ছে। আশাকরি আগের দুই পর্বের সীমাবদ্ধতা কাটিয়ে ভালো করে গাইতে পারবে।
তবে আমি অধীর আগ্রহে অপেক্ষা করছি নিশীতার কণ্ঠে শোনার জন্য: "অ্যাক নদী ড়ক্ত পেড়িয়ে, বাংলাড় আকাশে ড়ক্তিম সূড়যো আনলে যাড়া, আমড়া তোমাদেড় ভুলবো না..."উচ্চরণের উন্নয়ন ও কতোটা করতে পেরেছে, সেটা দেখার বিষয়। আমি আজ নিশিতার ফ্যান।:flamethro

karinawish · #52 12-15-2006, 09:05 PM

মাত্র সালমার গান শেষ হলো দেশাত্ববোধক পর্বে। বুলবুল যথারীতি ভাঁড়ামি করলেন। কয়েক লাইনের গান আগে থেকেই প্রস্তুত করে নিয়ে এসেছেন সালমা যেরকমই গান করুক, উনি একই জিনিস বলবেন। ফাহমিদা এককাঠি সরেস। উনি নাকি কোনো আবেগ পান নি। আমি বুঝি না, উনারা এরকম কেন। জাজ হয়েও এরকম ছেলেমানুষী করতে বাধে না?

আমার নিজস্ব মতামত, সালমা ভালোই গেয়েছে। গত দুটো পর্বের চাইতে অনেক ভালো। আবেগও যথেষ্ট। ওকে, অ্যাড শেষ। বাকিদের গান শুনি...

নিশিতার গান শেষ। উচ্চরণের কিছুটা উন্নতি হয়েছে; কিন্তু অনেক 'ড়' এখনো 'র'। আবেগ এনাফ। উচ্চরণ বাদে ভালোই হয়েছে।

মুহিন চমৎকার গেয়েছে। ভরাট কণ্ঠ। পারফেক্ট আবেগ। গানটা অন্যগুলোর চাইতে কম প্রচলিত। ওভারঅল, সিম্পলি সুপার্ব।

অনেক অপেক্ষার পর রন্টির গান শুনলাম। গান শোনার সময়ই মনে হচ্ছিলো, কোনো একটা সমস্যা আছে। গানটা অনেক কঠিন। অরিজিনালি মনে হয় রুনা লায়লার গাওয়া। এটাও একটা বাড়তি রিস্ক। পরে বুঝা গেলো, অসুস্থ। আবেগের অভাব বোধ হয়েছে। ওভারঅল ভালোই গেয়েছে। সবচেয়ে ভালো লেগেছে অসুস্থ বলে বাড়তি সহানুভূতি আদায়ের চেষ্টা না করা।

আমি জাজ হলে:
1। মুহিন - 50
2। সালমা - 40
3। রন্টি - 38
4। নিশীতা - 36

তবে জাজদের কাছ থেকে আমার ধারণা, সালমা সবচেয়ে কম মার্কস পাবে। আমার প্রেডিকশন, রন্টি পরবর্তীপর্বে বাদ(যদিও আমার ভোটের বেশির ভাগই ও পাবে)।

zazabor · #53 12-15-2006, 09:31 PM

Muhin azke sobar mone boshe zabe ..thats for sure.. asoley onek valo gaan gaise muhin..

Salma er por valo korse..last performance cheye valo hoise .. but i dont knw F.nobi'r sathe salma'r kono problem ase naki..tini to salmar kono kisu tei kono kisu khujhe pai na..

Nishita valoy gaise..F.nobi to pagol ee hoye gese..tar kotha sunle mone hoi Nishita gaan na sune morle taar jibon tai ee britha zaito..

bdmassimo · #54 12-15-2006, 09:34 PM

Vote For SALMA

সালমা k ভোট করুন [/size]:bestwishe

**shan** · #55 12-15-2006, 09:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by karinawish

.......... বুলবুল যথারীতি ভাঁড়ামি করলেন। ....... ফাহমিদা এককাঠি সরেস। উনি নাকি কোনো আবেগ পান নি। আমি বুঝি না, উনারা এরকম কেন। জাজ হয়েও এরকম ছেলেমানুষী করতে বাধে না?

Bulbul and Fahmida edited . মনের কথা বললাম , এডিট করলে করতে পারেন , দূঃখ নাই ।

bdmassimo · #56 12-15-2006, 09:40 PM

Rontir gaan ekhono shuni nai tar por o Muhin e Shera....:bestwishe

**TeolABM** · #57 12-15-2006, 09:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by karinawish

.......... বুলবুল যথারীতি ভাঁড়ামি করলেন। ....... ফাহমিদা এককাঠি সরেস। উনি নাকি কোনো আবেগ পান নি। আমি বুঝি না, উনারা এরকম কেন। জাজ হয়েও এরকম ছেলেমানুষী করতে বাধে না?

Fahmida should be kicked off from the judges' panel and Bulbul should be warned. Salma sang very well much better than Nishita. but Fahmida cannt die without listening Nishita's song and she didnt find any emotion in Salma's song! dusto lady!

napoleonIV · #58 12-15-2006, 09:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bdmassimo

Rontir gaan ekhono shuni nai tar por o Muhin e Shera....:bestwishe

So you acknowledge that Muhin is the best so far. But as implied by your earlier post, still you will vote for Salma and ask other to vote for Salma - right?

So much for objectivity........

bdmassimo · #59 12-15-2006, 10:33 PM

:bestwishe

N T V aaj Birokto Koira Sarse... Close Up 2006 k Rater Khobor er Pore Nia Asha te... Tar Por o Shes Holo...

Ja Hok SALMA ke Apnara Vote Din ekta Somvabonamoy Shilpi ke shamne egie jaoar jonno.

Amar Dristite Shera Tin

No 1)Salma

2)Muhin

3)Nishita

:bestwishe for them

napoleonIV · #60 12-16-2006, 04:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bdmassimo

Ja Hok SALMA ke Apnara Vote Din ekta Somvabonamoy Shilpi ke shamne egie jaoar jonno.

Amar Dristite Shera Tin

No 1)Salma

2)Muhin

3)Nishita

:bestwishe for them

Hi,

I am just curious. Have you put Salma at first position just based on her performance and you really believe Salma sang better than Muhin today? Or is it because you want to promote the cause of a " Somvabonamoy Shilpi " ?

Thanks.