Ami kintu comparison-ta last 2 rounds-er result-er modhdhe korechhi. Ete contestant matro 1 jon komechhe. Aar last round-er shei contestant Kishor vote peyechhilo 1,23,437. Shei shob vote-o jodi Muhin ei round-e peye thake tate or vote daray 3,45,629. Amar aager post-e point chhilo 2 ta. Firstly, Muhin-er vote 1 round-e 2,29,141 bere jaowa and Secondly, Salma-r vote 60,763 kome jaowa. Aar amar ei kotha gula bolar uddeshsho 1 tai- ato din Muhin gaan geye joto manusher mon joy korte perechhe, 1 round-e kanna kati kore taar 2 goon manusher mon joy korechhe. Othocho Muhin-er je quality ba ager performance tate highest vote or aro agei paowa uchit chhilo esp Band & Oldies rounds-e. BD-er people vote deyar shomoy ki gonnaboly dekhe vote dey sheta niye question tulatai chhilo amar main uddeshsho. Ete oneke hurt hote paren kintu ei kothagulo ami 2 ta Closeup1 dakhaar experience theke bolchhi.
Aar judge der appreciation-e vote 2 goon hoe jaowa!!! How funny! Bd-er people ki atoi boka je shudhu matro judge der comment shune vote dibe. Tahole to Ronty-r vote o 2 goon howa uchit chhilo.

This is just my opinion, please don't get me wrong. One thing I found common in between Nolok, Beauty and Salma; they always tried/try to use their family background when asking for votes. Last yr Nolok Babu did that, Beauty told some sad stories to the newspapers, and this year Salma did the same thing (Salmar baba bolese amar moto gareeb hoto doridro krishoker meye jodi kisu ekta hote pare). Eshob karone pablic talent-er cheye sympathy ke pradhanno diye dey beshi. Ami bolbo obossoi Salma khub valo gaan gae, ami nijeo Salma ke vote koresi, kintu ekta best singer ke ber korte hole amader sohanuvutir urdhe udhe sob kisu chinta kora uchit.

Please Salma fan jara asen amake khoma korben.:spankass:

Salma was getting very high votes from the audience long before her father commented about their family condition. his comment was simple and nothing to do with make people sympathicised to vote his daughter. so you cannot compare Salma with Nolok. last year ntv was showing the family condisiton earlier than this year.

but you can say that Muhin's kannakati made people vote for him enormously and it is true. he was singing well even earlier dounds. on the other hand, Salma did better performence in the last round than other two rounds, and still she got less vote.

Thanks TeolABM for your explanation.

actually I was talking about some newspapers too, they discovered Salma's family condition long before her father commented it on NTV. So ppl knew about her family condition from the begining. Anyway I am not saying she got only sympathy votes, but some extend it helped her to get more votes.

On the other hand, about Muhin, I don't know why he cried on that day!!! NTV could delete that portion, may be it was intentional. But I have to say his performance was excellent, and I also cried with him. I don't think only for crying he got 4 lakhs vote. At this point not only me, lot of other ppl also think he is the best among 3.

I am upset about Ronty. She was 2nd best and she was out. But Nishita, her performance was so poor and she got 43 from judges. To me Salma and Nishita's performances were below 40 standard. They got more points than they deserved. Again it's my opinion only.

Thanks all.

Buddy, after reading ur comments I really didnt get that what u want to say. Before this round, mohin got 2,70,000 votes but this round got more than450000 votes (i dont know exact vote coz ntv fare to show us all contestent number properly). How come he made his vote double without this famous crying!!!If u live overseas, I thing u know that close up1 website down first 13 hours in last voting day. Isnt it funny to get too much vote after this incident. Some newspaper all got conspernency smell in their, If u dont believe me just go through last Monday's Jiajiadin (entertainment) & protom-alo (deshir khobur), then u will find that urself. I agree with u that Mohin is good singer. But I believe that he is much more good actor than singer!!!

U also said salma deserves less than 40 number. I dont know, u heard or not, kumar biswjit comment after ronty's perfomence. He said she didnt sing well for her illness. After that comments how come ronty got 48 number from judges. Isnt it funny for u. U know what, If salma deserved less than 40 points from judge, then ronty deserved less than 20 points from judges. But what a joke, thats not happen.
Dont worry, ur mohin will be close up1 coz close up1 administration & some stupid judges want that. Whatever we, most public want that or not. Oh one more thing, F nubi (who even dont deserve to sit in judge panel & make comments) with mohin whatever he will sing (good or ka ka ka).....

Dude !!!
A bit aggressive reply/comment :poke: ........
But liked it anyway........:hahaha:

__________________
shan@banglatorrents.com

U r right TeolABM bhai. Although I'm an avid supporter of Muhin, I didn't like the way he got those enormous votes. He deserves these votes having very good quality as a singer (in many people's opinion including mine, he should be Closeup1). Maybe his emotion was genuine but it's not fair to become first by getting sympathy/emotional votes. I don't know when ppl of BD will cast their votes to original quality singer who deserves to be Closeup1 (not being driven by emotion) :adore:

[/color]

I have no strong opinion on Muhin's weeping; if it was genuine or just acting. I did not like it either, because it could be a means to draw public sympathy. I did not like the acting of Polash as well. But it's simply my personal opinion. I am not going to hurt their emotion, if it was true.

Anyway, I think, the emotion stuff is not the main reason of Muhin's vote increase. He was the standout performer in the previous 2 rounds and he was again the best, without any doubt, in this round. Many of the sensible people just had enough with the likes of Salma or Nishita or Ronty; all of them failed to perform to their expectation.

__________________

Thanks mamun092 for your comments.:flamethro

last year Nolok and Rajib's vote was also doubled in the final round (nolok 7 lakh, Rajib 4 lakh), but Beauty's vote decreased to half (3 lakh theke 1.5 lakh) and it is normal. You never know why ppl are voting and why not voting. I guess at the end of the show after watching all these episodes ppl will be more carefull and will try to correct themselves. Unless someone blindly supports a singer will change his/her mind and will vote for the best.

I am not a blind supporter of Muhin. To me Ronty was the best, if she was not sick that day she had the capability to make 50 from judges (because her standard is A+) and I don't blame kumar biswjit who was expecting more from her even after that awesome performance. Because as a music literate he has the ability to see who has more talents. After all these performances if anyone expect more from Nishita or Salma that would be unrealistic.

mamun092 said " with mohin whatever he will sing (good or ka ka ka) "
I think this is more appropriate for Nishita or Salma. Whatever they will sing will get lakh lakh votes...

I will be happy if Muhin becomes closeup 1, because among 3 I don't see anyone else who has the quality to win 1st position.:)

But in a competition like closeup1 (final), I am not ready to see another cry drama :bawling: or not ready to hear a sad story (need extra care :gtfo: because I am impoverished :loadstear ). That's all.

Thanks everybody and you can start now... :fight: :boxing:

__________________
<TrY 2 SeE mE iN mY WaY>

Yes I agree with you, how come no one is talking about Mr Bulbul. Today Salma's performance was full of mis-pronounciations (Pran -> Pan, Prio-> Pio) still he was so happy and again praised her!!!

বাংলায় একটা কথা আছে...............
'ওস্তাদের মাইর শ্যাষ রাইতে'

সালমা দেখাইয়া দিছে.........না, ভুল বলছি, শুনাইয়া দিছে.........

:bestwishe To Salma

__________________
shan@banglatorrents.com