thanksss for this gr8 release

Salma just slaps on One of the Judge:spankass: ... 2day SALMA proves She is not only gift for us but also gift for music of BD.. CAN'T HELP WITHOUT VOTING HER THIS TIME. :bestwishe

Muhin's 2nd song just shocked me .. Moulik gaan aro beshi melodious howya lagto .. gaan ta khub normal hoye gese .. Ar Andrw Kishorer aro to gaan silo ai kothin gaan ta choose kora tao muhiner vul hoise..

NIshita'r 2nd gaan ta onek valo hoise..but 1st gaan ta ato beshi naki naki :bawling: hoye gese ze ki bolbo.. Disappointing:ciao:

AND mostly thanx toelABM bro for gr8 service from the Beginning of closeup1.:adore:

overall Muhin is the best in this round. His second song was simply awesome.
Nishita's first song was also good.

i cannot agree with you.

Here are some points:
1. ntv authority is against Salma
2. two of the judges are agains Salma
3. f.nabi commented very badly after Salma's last performences and gave poor points.
4. Salma could hold her place with the support of people. (Salma is the singer of people who represent 80% of BD population!)

two of the judges dont like Salma and surely they will give her as low mark as possible like the recent round where Salma's performence was much better then Nishita. but she recieved only 40 and Nishita being so poor perfomence recieved 43. ar Ront ý being sick and performed wors than Salma got 47 from judges.

so, even this final round F. Nabi and Kumar will give her less vote. F. Nabi already told indirectly that Salma is too young and she has whole life in front. and in the future she will sing even better. that means according to F. Nabi Salma didnt sing so well. poor dusto lady!

we need vote for Salma even more to cover the injustice of judges!

thxz bro..for ur quick post....

I totally agree with u. I dont know F.nabi jelous to salma for Salma's popularity or she blindes supporter of Muhin. But after today's performence salma just shalpe that old foolish lady. Even most popular newspaper made artical abut close up1 consperency & judges. If u dont believe just, read last 10 days newspaper (e.g prothom alo, jiajiadin, amardesh etc), then u will find that. And I hope salma's best, SALMA PROVES THAT WHO IS REAL TALENT ,WHO HAS MORE POTENTIALITY THAN ANY OTHER CONTESTENTS.........

I was travelling whole day and couldn't watch the program live. Thanks to TeolABM bhai, now I will watch now, :). From the comments, I guess Nishita is getting third place! Who is going to be close up 1? Salma or Muhin.

Just finished watching the final round. Nishita sang well. Muhin did very well. Specially his second song was awesome! Salma's performance was poor with her same old pronunciation problem [Mod edit: the problem you are talking abt is not any mistake. rather original song is like that. it is the language of 80% BD people who live in the village. so please dont do any sich comments! Salma is from that part of BD where even iliterate people talk pure Bangla. i know because my wife is from that area! -TeolABM] and very similar repeated style in which she is singing all the time. Muhin is the best among these three. In my judgment:

Muhin 50

Nishita 45

Salma 37
__________________________________________


[Reply to TeolABM's comment] I also speak that language. I don't say kheyechi or korechi instead I say khaisi and korsi. But my point was that Salma has pronuciation problems with 'juktakhkhor' which she should have recovered by now. I am not talking about those pronunciations like 'istitationer rel garita' which is like that in the original song. But Salma sang pan bondhu (should be pran bondhu), pio (prio), diver (driver), pem (prem). I don't think 80% of us have this problem. I hope I have made myself clear about 'pronunciation problem'.

I am sharing my same feelings with you Shan !

Go ! Salma Priyo Dorshinii Go !!!!! You are The Best Salma Priyo Dorshinii !!!!!:) :) :) :) :) :)


Thanks
Babu
Delray Beach,FL
[oh man! shokalbela PC khulei jodi ebhabe post edit korte hoy, tao jodi emon ekjoner je naki dedicated person for Salma....!

TeolABM]

At first, thanx to TeolABM bhai for yr continuous great effort. U rock.

Now I'll comment about the performance of the last round:

Nishita- Her performance was excellent in the 1st song.
Her 2nd song was very melodious, a nice composition of lyrics & music. She started the song very badly but could recover then. Still I don't think her performance was up to the mark in the 2nd song.

Muhin- Chose a tough song as A. Kishore's voice is unique. But Muhin tried his best & performed best. He was marvelous, in a word.
He also sang the 2nd song very well. What I feel that the song was not so melodious esp the lyrics were not much well.

Salma- Performance in the 1st song was good but her pronunciation is awful. The 2nd song was a nice song with rich lyrics & music but she performed poor in that song. Her voice was more harsh than melodious in this song, let alone, pronunciation. When I was hearing her 2nd song by my headphone & keeping my eyes closed(as per TeolABM bhai's advice), it seemed to me that someone was shouting in my ears.

To me:
Nishita- 43 marks
Muhin- 49 marks
Salma- 37 marks

Apnar ei line gulate kamon jeno 1 ta forum-er gondho paowa jachchhe. Okhankar admin Closeup1-er protita porbo jekhane release diye thaken, taar heading-e thik ei kothagulo likhe dan.

ferdous bai, I thing u never heard salma's 1st song before salma's performence. Otherwise u cant said that there have pronuciation problem coz thats not her pronuciation mistake, thats the main lyrics. Plz heard the main singer's song, after that make any so called prounciation mistakes comment. I thing u grown up in town. thats why u thought there have pronuciation mistakes. I m sure ur father's root come from village. So dont make any that sort of comments abut our village language (80% pplz of our country still talk like that way). If u do that, that mean u critisized ur own father!!!!
Yeah u r right. My previous comment's last sentence is come from website. I am modereator in that site.
One more thing, salma's performence is awesome. So go salma go............

sorry bhai. shob somoy shob nojore pore na. you can always let us know bad post report!

some opf members you are talking abt the pronounciation problem of Salma's song it is not any mistake. rather original song is like that. it is the language of 80% BD people who live in the village. so please dont do any sich comments! Salma is from that part of BD where even iliterate people talk pure Bangla.

Don't think yrself always as an intellectual. U don't have to teach me about bengali language [Mod Edit: please avoid such kind of attack. I know you are replying his post. we advise all not to use offensive words]. I've very good idea about my language. I also speak in my village language like "khaichhi", "gechhi" etc in my home. But when I talk in front of unknown people or in any seminar or other official places I use the words "kheyechhi", "giyechhi" etc (& I think most of u do this, not only me). Even when we write in this forum we write "Ami gaan-ti shunechhi, vaalo legechhe" in stead of "Ami gaan-ta shunchhi, vaalo lagse". Salma is from a village, we all know. But u've to improvise yrself when u gonna sing a song in original lyrics. Nishita/Ronty (& their families) speaks in Chittagonian language. Can u tell that when u hear her song?
I've very good idea about u & yr forum(where u r a moderator). Days before Salma's performance in the third round, u started yelling "Plz vote for Salma" etc. In Closeup1 video posted in yr site, u waste lower 1/3rd of that video by writing that sentence (in a black background). [Mod Add: please download all the mp3 or video songs of Salma from the other sections. then comments such harsh abt Salma who is just a God-gifted talent. if you want to comment abt the other site then go to that site and cput your comment there. Dont start a caos here, please.] And u always promise 5 /7 /10 new drama to give as a gift, if Salma won. And u edit their posts who write for Muhin/Nishita/Ronty or against Salma. Is it fair to do all these?
Sorry to all BT member for telling these here. Because they never posted mine or other people's post there as we r not a supporter of Salma. Everybody has his/her own right to vote for his/her favourite contestant. I'll never ask any Salma fan to vote for Muhin. It's their choice. I just wrote what I felt after hearing the songs. U may have different opinion, so u can oppose me but not by hurting me. For example, go thru' TeolABM or Shan bhai's posts. They r great fans of Salma. They oppose me or other people. But in a decent way. They don't hurt other people but u did it by directly attacking me in an aggresive language. So, mind yr own language. Then try to teach other people.